Alex Holden (alex_holden) wrote,
Alex Holden
alex_holden

Torchwood

I saw the third episode of Torchwood last night and loved it. Great cameo role for Gareth Thomas, who played the title character in Blake's Seven. I doubt it was a coincidence that they ran a supernatural-themed story near Halloween. As others have said, I too was expecting the ghost of the little boy lost in the railway station to ask, "Are you my mummy?"

It always felt to me like the new series of Doctor Who were trying just that little bit too hard to be something they weren't. Holding onto some old traditions like the ubiquitous Sonic Screwdriver while abandoning others such as the design of the Tardis control room made it seem slightly schizophrenic. Torchwood is free to be its own thing without forty years of prior tradition, and it takes full advantage of that.

John Barrowman as Captain Jack Harkness is just as cool as he was in Doctor Who, Eve Myles as Gwen Cooper is simultaneously intelligent, driven, vulnerable and gorgeous (I love that "giant eyes" thing she does when she's surprised), Gareth David-Lloyd as Ianto Jones is intriguing (I'd be surprised if he doesn't end up with a bigger role in later episodes), and Burn Gorman as Owen Harper is just as bizarre as he was in Bleak House. Naoko Mori as Toshiko Sato (who formerly had a cameo in Doctor Who) seems a bit underutilised at this point - come on Russell, give her a few alien corpses to dissect!

I'm finding it impossible to avoid comparing Torchwood to that other new BBC series, Robin Hood. I was expecting Torchwood to suck, frankly, and have been pleasantly surprised by how good it is. Robin Hood on the other hand seems to have missed the target. The actors are all smug, irritating, and far too pretty for their own good. Keith Allen provides some comic relief as a caricature of The Evil Sheriff of Nottingham, but it's not enough to hold the series together, and the issues explored in the stories (the effects on the English peasant class of being taxed into the ground to fund a religious war in the Middle East) are so oversimplified that you have to be careful not to think or it all unravels. As a result I'm having a hard time suspending disbelief long enough to enjoy the series for what it is - light entertainment with archery and silly costumes.
Tags: tv
Subscribe

  • Loncon 3 Con Report

    A couple of weeks ago I attended this year's Worldcon, Loncon 3, at the Excel Centre in London. After a couple of false starts on this report I've…

  • Queen Victoria and Highland Soldier Marionettes à la Planchette

    I was recently commissioned by a Punch and Judy professor to make a pair of marionettes à la planchette depicting an elderly Queen Victoria and a…

  • Jig Dog

    I recently made a simple jig doll (limberjack) dog for my niece's birthday. It's loosely based on my mum's Yorkshire Terrier, Amber. I made her…

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.
  • 1 comment